Hammer&Hope

Menu

No. 2

“We Don’t Struggle for You, We Struggle with You”

Socialist shack dwellers fight for land and housing in South Africa.

Hero Image for “We Don’t Struggle for You, We Struggle with You”

A woman walks through a meeting hall during National Women’s Day celebrations while members chant “Amandla!” (“power”). It was a popular rallying cry during apartheid resistance. Photographs by Siyabonga Mbhele (LordbearPictures) for Hammer & Hope.

On August 9, Abahlali baseMjondolo (AbM), a mass movement of socialist shack dwellers based in Durban, South Africa, celebrated National Women’s Day, a public holiday in memory of the more than 20,000 Black, Indian, colored, and white women who in 1956 marched in Pretoria demanding the repeal of the pass laws that prevented Black people from entering areas of white occupation. For AbM, that holiday is also a time to mourn and remember the lives of 24 members assassinated since 2009 in the struggle for land and housing. Last year, four of them were gunned down at the movement’s settlements. The movement believes that ANC politicians are behind most of the killings.

Photo Gallery Image

Portraits of assassinated Abahlali baseMjondolo members on display during the movement’s commemorative event on August 20, 2023, at the eKhenana settlement, located in Cato Manor, a historically working-class area in Durban.

Photo Gallery Image

The Abahlali baseMjondolo isicathamiya group performs during the General Assembly meeting on August 6, 2023. Isicathamiya is an a cappella singing style originated by the South African Zulu people that is defined by its harmonies and the singers’ choreographed dance moves.

Inline image for “We Don’t Struggle for You, We Struggle with You”

A member of the Abahlali baseMjondolo movement wearing a “Socialism or Death” T-shirt. The slogan was popularized by Lindokuhle Mnguni, a prominent leader of the movement who was assassinated on August 20, 2022.

Photo Gallery Image

Community members listen to speeches made by Abahlali baseMjondolo leadership during the August 6 General Assembly meeting. They live in eNkanini, an informal settlement on municipal land in Bonela, just outside the business district.

Photo Gallery Image

AbM has about 115,000 members spread across 81 branches in the southeast of South Africa. Since its founding in 2005, the movement has fought for access to land and housing along with basic services, like sanitation and electricity. The movement’s struggles, which include defending poor workers from evictions in big cities, expose the social inequality and racial discrimination that remain as lasting conditions of the apartheid era.

Inline image for “We Don’t Struggle for You, We Struggle with You”

Thapelo Mohapi speaks to community members during the August 6 General Assembly meeting.

“The movement first and foremost has a principle that we don’t struggle for you, we struggle with you,” explained Thapelo Mohapi, AbM’s general secretary. Contrary to conventional social movements, AbM does not rely on elected representatives to channel its demands. Instead, the movement maintains that landless and homeless workers should speak and act for themselves. They do that by organizing protests, presenting demands to state authorities, democratically managing settlements where they grow subsistence crops, and opening and running political schools. With such acts, AbM synthesizes direct action with grassroots self-determination.

Inline image for “We Don’t Struggle for You, We Struggle with You”

A child crosses a bridge that leads to the other side of the eKhenana settlement.

Photo Gallery Image

A resident of the eKhenana settlement heads to the community garden.

Photo Gallery Image

Women farming in the eKhenana settlement, which is in Cato Manor, a historically working-class area in Durban.

Mohapi emphasized the strategic importance of AbM’s bottom-up internal architecture, saying, “It is only when people are democratically organized from below that they can change the system that oppresses them.” AbM’s structure enables democratic participation at the grassroots and top levels. Local councils from each branch bring demands to a forum of elected chairs and then to the National Council. The movement’s General Assembly, open to all members, meets once a month to set priorities for the National Council and can potentially disband any structure of the movement if members feel their demands are being ignored.

Inline image for “We Don’t Struggle for You, We Struggle with You”

A member of the Abahlali baseMjondolo movement dances during the isicathamiya group’s performance.

Photo Gallery Image

Abahlali baseMjondolo members listen to speeches during the August 6 General Assembly meeting.

Photo Gallery Image

Women play a key role in the councils and daily life of the settlements. But few had occupied leadership roles as recently as 2016, even though 60 percent of all members were women. Zandile Nsibande, a community facilitator, explained that “women were scared to participate and compete in elections for leadership. They were having low self-esteem.”

Inline image for “We Don’t Struggle for You, We Struggle with You”

Abahlali baseMjondolo members at the commemoration for fallen leaders held on August 20, 2023, a year after their deaths.

So that year, the AbM Women’s League undertook a campaign to collectively fight for gender equality within the movement’s leadership. “Through this campaign women and men are now 50/50” in leadership, Nsibande said. Along with increasing women’s participation in decision-making and waging campaigns against gender-based violence and feminicide, the league has advocated for women’s financial independence in particular. It has held workshops on women’s access to land and increased awareness of harmful traditional practices, including the requirement that a woman marry a man before she can own land. The league also encourages women to learn new skills, such as traditional jewelry and dressmaking, highlighting the importance of sharing technical knowledge. “If someone knows how to make dresses, then she must teach others how to do so. In South Africa, job opportunities are scarce, so we need to empower ourselves financially,” Nsibande said. The Women’s League seeks donations to open a training center where the women of AbM can learn how to sew.

Photo Gallery Image

The mother of Lindokuhle Mnguni watches her grandchild play. The movement is building them a new home in KwaSwayimane, on the outskirts of Pietermaritzburg.

Photo Gallery Image

The Frantz Fanon Political School in the eKhenana settlement, which also serves as a community hall. The building is adorned with the movement name and the names of fallen members.


Building an autonomous shack dwellers movement that integrates social, political, racial, and gender struggles has triggered what Mohapi calls a “politics of blood.” In addition to the assassinations and evictions, the movement has been impacted by unlawful police raids, detentions, and death threats. In a 2022 letter to President Cyril Ramaphosa, signed by more than 130 civil society organizations, the human-rights organization Socio-Economic Rights Institute of South Africa denounced the fact that “at least 24 leaders of the movement have been threatened and killed, hundreds have been injured and thousands displaced from their homes.”

Photo Gallery Image

Abahlali baseMjondolo members wearing T-shirts with the faces of Lindokuhle Mnguni and Nokuthula Mabaso, fallen leaders, during the August 20 commemorative event at the eKhenana settlement.

Photo Gallery Image

An Abahlali baseMjondolo members wearing T-shirts with the face of Ayanda Ngila, a fallen leaders, during the August 20 commemorative event at the eKhenana settlement.

Despite these attacks, AbM continues to resist and preserve the legacies of its fallen members. AbM has held ceremonies in their memory at the Frantz Fanon Political School, located in the eKhenana community, the epicenter of the recent attacks. AbM teaches the communist values and humanist worldview that characterize the movement. AbM remains united in its goals of land, housing, and popular self-determination.

Inline image for “We Don’t Struggle for You, We Struggle with You”

Sinothando Mkhize sits outside the Frantz Fanon Political School. Founded in 2019 after the assassination of Lindokuhle Mnguni, it provides a political education to members of the eKhenana community.

Siyabonga Mbhele was born in Pietermaritzburg and is now based in Johannesburg. He works as a video editor and a documentary photographer.

Hammer & Hope is free to read. Become a monthly donor, sign up for our mailing list, and follow us on Instagram.

Back

Previous Article

Next Article

Next
More From This Issue